Editors – ‘Surface, Echo & Sound’ album review

Editors return with their eighth studio album ‘Surface, Echo & Sound’, released via Play It Again Sam Records on 30 October, 2026. The record finds them heading back to their roots and embracing a more organic sound – inspired by frontman Tom Smith’s acoustic sketches – than on 2022’s electronically tinged ‘EBM’.

Opening with the title track, there’s a DIY feeling from the first note albeit with a touch of ‘Nebraska’-style pining, as Tom laments over the quiet and understated instrumentation: ‘I don’t grieve just to cross the street. We’ve all got our problems’. This is followed by the more familiar angular post-punk sound of ‘Call It In’. Pacy and pulsating, its synth-driven hooks wrap around the assertive directions: ‘It all breaks down, get on your knees and kiss the ground’.

Big drums and a mandolin sound signal the start of the incessantly catchy ‘The Rush’ – an anthemic song that sits somewhere between U2 and The War on Drugs with just the right amount of candour: ‘This living hurts, it’s never ending’. ‘Rescue’ continues in this melancholic space, but with more industrial backing, while ‘Shadow’ finds Tom laying his demons bare with talk of all things getting dark and heavy. He turns this into a comforting pep talk, first reassuring the subject ‘I’ll be your shadow’ and then urging them: ‘Don’t give up without me, I can’t face the aftermath’.

Americana meets Frightened Rabbit on ‘Real’ while ‘Happiness’ has an assertive, almost accusatory tone: ‘Did you figure it out? Did you fuck? You misunderstand. Make the streets smell like Disneyland’ (on a side note, we once saw Tom in Disneyland in California…) ‘Much Love’ is more gothic and wiry as you’re asked to ‘watch the birds fly home’ and ‘Butterfly Wings’ is deeply atmospheric and introspective indie rock: ‘All the last goodbyes scattered on a wing’.

‘Seriously’ finds the band dipping into ’80s power pop in the vein of The Replacements and has an upbeat message at its core – ‘Seriously, it’s OK, what’s the world gonna do?’ – before ‘The Hills We Died Upon’ rounds off the album in a sparser space closer to the opener. Tom delivers stream of consciousness thoughts that show how important companionship can be: ‘Those dreams will always fade’; ‘Curtain falls down on your pillow. You beat a different drum, you separate my thumb. Hold me when I’m numb’.

Eight albums in and Editors are still climbing high. ‘Surface, Echo & Sound’ is a record that soars.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.